The first annual Starlet Madness tournament was held in March 2013.
The four #1 seeds were:
2013 AVN Female Performer of the Year Asa Akira
2013 AVN Best New Starlet Remy LaCroix
2013 XBIZ Female Performer of the Year Brooklyn Lee
2013 XBIZ Best New Starlet Riley Reid
April O’Neil won the vote in poll to claim the final spot in the tournament, defeating 19 other starlets with 50% of the vote. She would go on to eliminate Brooklyn Lee, India Summer, Kristina Rose, Alexis Texas, and Jynx Maze on her way to the finals.
Gianna Michaels won the 2013 Starlet Madness Tournament eliminating Kelly Divine, Rita Faltoyano, Tory Lane, Tori Black, Lexi Belle, and April O’Neil on her path to the title.